What is debt consolidation (and is it right for you?)

Debt consolidation is a way to combine multiple debts into one loan, but whether it is the right choice depends on your financial situation. For some Australians, it can simplify repayments and reduce interest, while for others, a structured personal budget may be a more effective way to get out of debt. The best option comes down to your income, expenses, and ability to manage repayments long term.

Do you feel like every debt repayment you make disappears into the black hole of interest charges? It is easy to feel stuck, especially when multiple debts, rising costs, and unpredictable expenses are all colliding at once.

The truth is, there isn’t one “right” solution. The right path is the one that actually works for your life, your income, and your spending patterns.

The results can be significant when people have the right plan in place:

95% of surveyed MyBudget clients who previously missed repayments have not missed a repayment since joining MyBudget.*

Debt consolidation is the process of combining multiple separate debts into a single, new loan, usually with a lower interest rate and just one regular repayment to manage. In Australia, debt consolidation is most commonly used to combine credit cards, personal loans and buy now pay later (BNPL) debts into one repayment.

Instead of trying to keep track of different lenders, varying interest charges, and fluctuating due dates, you use a new personal loan, credit card, or mortgage refinance to pay off your existing liabilities. This leaves you with a single lender, one interest rate, and one fixed repayment schedule to cover your debts.

People often use a debt consolidation loan to:

• Consolidate credit card debt
• Combine personal loans, store cards, BNPL accounts, and car loans
• Reduce high interest charges
• Simplify debt repayments, manage bills, and explore bill consolidation options to ease cash flow.

Can you consolidate debt into one payment?

Yes. Debt consolidation allows you to combine multiple eligible debts into one repayment, usually through a new debt consolidation loan with a fixed repayment schedule.

Here is how the process typically works in Australia:

• You apply for a debt consolidation loan through a bank, credit union, or specialist lender
• The lender reviews your credit report, income, day-to-day expenses, and overall affordability
• If approved, the funds from the new loan are used to pay off your old accounts (for example, credit cards, store cards, or personal loans)
• You begin making one regular repayment based on the new term, interest rate, and fees.

What are the two main types of debt consolidation loans?

The two main types of debt consolidation loans are secured loans, which require you to put up an asset as collateral, and unsecured loans, which do not require security.

• • Secured loan: This is backed by an asset you own, such as your car or home equity. These loans typically offer lower interest rates, but your asset is at risk of repossession if your repayments are not met
  • Unsecured loan: No asset is required. Because the lender is taking on more risk, these loans usually carry higher interest rates, stricter approval rules, and may result in higher monthly repayments.

Which option you are offered, and what it costs, depends on your credit profile, income stability, and ability to meet the new repayment. The right choice ultimately comes down to your financial situation and how much risk you are comfortable taking.

To consolidate debt successfully, the final outcome must genuinely reduce the overall cost of your debt and ease the day-to-day pressure on your household budget. The key is not just the steps you take, but whether the outcome actually improves your situation.

Before you consolidate, make sure:

• The interest rate is lower: The interest rate on the new loan must be strictly lower than the average of what you are currently paying
• The total cost is lower: Check the total cost over the life of the loan, including set-up and ongoing account fees. A longer loan term might offer lower monthly repayments, but it gives interest more time to compound, making the debt more expensive in the long run
• The budget fits comfortably: The new repayment must fit easily within your actual cash flow, leaving plenty of room for everyday living costs
• You have a behavioral plan: You must have a strategy to avoid relying on credit cards or BNPL services again after your old balances are cleared.

In simple terms, consolidation works when it reduces both the cost of your debt and the pressure on your cash flow. If it doesn’t do both, it can set you back rather than move you forward.

If consolidation is the right path for you, working with the right lending support can make a big difference. MyBudget Loans has lending experts who help assess your situation and make the process simpler

Clients refinancing through MyBudget Loans save on average $10,000 per year in repayments.*

You can use our free Personal Loan & Debt Consolidation Calculator to see what your combined payments could look like.

Debt consolidation can be a good idea when it reduces your overall costs and fits comfortably within your budget, helping you stick to a clear and manageable repayment plan.

But here is the part people often miss: debt consolidation does not automatically equal debt relief, and a new loan does not fix the reason the debt built up in the first place.

If spending habits do not change, it is very easy to fall back into using credit again, leaving you trying to manage the new loan repayments on top of brand-new credit card balances, and if the loan term is extended too far, you can end up paying significantly more interest over time. This is especially true if you are only making minimum credit card repayments, which can increase the true cost of making only minimum repayments over the life of your debt.

If you are weighing up debt consolidation vs budgeting, this is where things become clearer. Debt consolidation and personal budgeting solve two very different structural problems:

• Debt consolidation restructures your debt
• Personal budgeting changes how your money is managed day to day.

Here is how they compare side by side:

The best solution depends on whether your biggest issue is structure or cash flow pressure.

When debt consolidation makes sense

Debt consolidation can work well when your debt is technically manageable, but messy and expensive. It may be the right fit if:

• You are paying high interest rates across multiple separate debts
• You can comfortably afford your repayments but find the administration disorganised
• A lower interest rate on a new loan will genuinely reduce your total out-of-pocket costs.

When personal budgeting is the better option

Personal budgeting is often the safer and more sustainable option when the issue isn’t just the layout of your debt, but a persistent pressure on your day-to-day cash flow. It may be the better fit if:

• You are already struggling to meet your minimum monthly payments or are falling behind on bills
• Your regular income does not comfortably cover your basic living expenses and your debts
• You find yourself relying on credit cards, overdrafts, or BNPL apps just to make it to your next pay.

The truth about debt consolidation that most people do not realise

Debt consolidation can feel like progress because everything becomes “simpler” on paper. But if the repayment still does not fit your budget, or your spending habits do not change, it can quietly make things worse over time.

A strong budget, on the other hand, might feel slower at the start, but it actually changes your relationship with money and teaches you how to build a structured personal budget plan that actually lasts.

Over half of surveyed MyBudget clients (51.4%) no longer have a credit card after getting their finances under control.*

Kim & Bob: when debt consolidation created breathing room

When Kim and Bob found themselves facing an unexpected crisis due to serious health challenges and sudden income loss, they were juggling 12 separate debts and struggling to survive. Mainstream lenders declined their application for a debt consolidation loan, leaving them feeling completely stuck and unsure where to turn.

Back in Vanuatu, we only spent the money we had in our hands. In Australia, tapping a card felt like free money, until the banks started calling.

Bob | MyBudget client

Through MyBudget Loans, they were able to consolidate their debts into one manageable repayment and regain control of their finances.

• Their 12 high-interest debts were combined into one manageable loan
• Collection calls stopped and financial pressure eased
• They gained breathing room and a clear path forward.

Within 15 months, we were completely debt-free.

Kim | MyBudget client

The difference: Debt consolidation worked for Kim and Bob because it simplified their repayments and created the structure they needed to move forward with confidence.

Debbie & Alan: when budgeting was the solution

Debbie and Alan were juggling multiple credit cards and personal loans, with repayments that left them financially and emotionally drained. They believed a consolidation loan was their only way out, until their application was declined.

We were scared to answer the phone, we knew it was just another creditor chasing money we didn’t have.

Alan | MyBudget client

For them, consolidation was not the right fit, not because it wouldn’t simplify things, but because the repayments still would not have been affordable based on their regular income and living expenses.

Instead of taking on more debt, they worked with MyBudget to create a structured budget plan and have their creditor negotiations handled professionally on their behalf.

Within a short period:

• Repayments were restructured into amounts they could actually afford each week
• Creditor pressure reduced and some late fees were negotiated down
• Essential living expenses were covered without falling behind
• A savings buffer was built for unexpected costs.

53.3% of surveyed MyBudget clients now have at least $1,000 set aside for emergencies, proving that starting a dedicated emergency savings fund builds true household resilience.*

The difference: Budgeting worked better for Debbie and Alan because it reduced the pressure on their cash flow without adding another loan, giving them a plan they could actually sustain long term.

You can read Debbie and Alan’s full success story to see how they cleared their debts and built a real savings buffer without taking on another loan.

It comes down to one honest question:

Is your problem the number of debts… or the pressure on your money?

• If it is structure → debt consolidation may help
• If it is cash flow pressure → budgeting is often the better first step.

In many cases, the most effective approach is a combination of both, done in the right order. It is okay if consolidation isn’t the right fit for you. The right plan is simply the one you can actually stick to, and that is what leads to real progress.

Before taking out any new loan, take a step back and look at your full financial picture:

• Your income and expenses
• Your total debt and interest rates
• What you can realistically afford to repay.

Because the goal isn’t just to “manage debt”. It is to get out of it, and stay out of it.

Download our free 10 Steps to Get Out of Debt eBook for a step-by-step plan to start tackling what you owe.

Debt consolidation is not your only option. In some situations, alternatives can be more effective, especially if the issue is affordability rather than simply managing multiple repayments.

Depending on your circumstances, alternatives might include a structured personal budget, creditor hardship support, or a debt management plan designed to reduce financial pressure without taking on a new loan.

Read our full guide on alternatives to debt consolidation to explore these options in detail.

At MyBudget, we provide professional debt help and debt relief to help Australians reduce debt, manage repayments, and build financial stability without the stress. For over 25 years, we have helped more than 130,000 Australians take back control of their money.

We can:

• Create a personalised debt repayment plan
• Negotiate with creditors to reduce payments and fees
• Help you understand whether debt consolidation is right for you
• Build a budget that supports long-term financial stability.

92.6% of surveyed MyBudget clients reported that their financial stress reduced significantly after getting their budget plan in place.*

More than anything, we give you clarity. And once you have that, the right decision becomes much easier.

Before jumping into a consolidation loan, make sure it actually improves your situation.

The right plan will reduce money stress, not just reshuffle it.

Ready to find out what options will work best for your life?

Enquire online

Or call 1300 300 922 today to book a free, no-obligation chat with one of our Money Coaches.

* Stats based on a 2026 survey of 741 MyBudget clients.* Average savings figure based on internal MyBudget Loans client data.